My dad has a Vista and I have a quick fish 3. We both have fished out of them in the last few weeks. The quick fish seems to be the better shanty in my opinion. The windows come out is pretty much the difference. They both seem to be built the same way but the zippers are tighter on the Vista and 2 have broken off already. The center cap on the Vista also fell off inside the first time we used it. The nut was striped. No problems with the Eskimo so far.