Buckeye lake - small jiggin rap, small clam Psyco Shad, sweedish pimple, and the pulse work not to aggressive bringing the Saugeye up from the bottom.
Indian lake the same baits but with a more aggressive motion. They seem to be more agresive and hit it a lot on the fall. Might move up in size.
Alum - I start with the same but larger size because we are fishing deeper and the Saugeye seem to like the larger presentation.
This works for me but there are many ways to catch them.
CRV puts out a mine field of tip ups and does well.
Colors- nuetral when clear And darker or chartreuse in dirty water.
Good luck Hope this helps.
David