Depends on what you want to fish for, indian has a good mixxed bag, lots of eater size eyes, huge perch, gills, and decent crappies, its hit and miss so for the drive i would plan a couple days trip. buckeye lake has a good mixxed bag also its simular in many ways to indian, alum is a good crappie spot, it also is a good eye lake if u know where to fsh and from my exspereince the eyes seem to be alittle bigger when u do get on them, alum doesn't have the greatest ice right now so if ur planning to go soon i would plan a trip to indian. but remember no ice is safe so be careful.